The myth of an attempt at an American Christian Theocracy


Posted On: Thursday - January 18th 2024 9:03AM MST
In Topics: 
  History  Americans  ctrl-left  Bible/Religion



Peak Stupidity's commenter Dieter Kief brought up a point of medium-recent American history to my mind with a comment of his under this post on Church hymns. In response to Alarmist's posting of the youtube link to the 2-minute rant/song Moral Majority by The Dead Kennedys, Mr. Kief provided the lyrics, some background of the band members' names, and interesting fodder for this post. We've got to think back to a little over 4 decades back.

The Dead Kennedys recorded the album In God We Trust, Inc. in the summer of 1981, and it was released that December. Moral Majority, the title taken from a term used in pride by said "moral majority" of the day, was one of 8 tracks on the album. Mr. Kief provided the song's lyrics for us in his comment, but I'll only insert a couple of verses, their being too long, though they were amazingly sung in 2 minutes! (Speed punk or regular old punk, I'm no big connoisseur?)

Let me think back to those early '80s years for the background. I don't know how religious President Ronald Reagan really was, but he was less overtly Christian than his predecessor Jimmy Carter. However, as Conservative as he may seem now, Jimmy was politically with the ctrl-left of the time. The idea that America would get back to the Christian-leaning (at the least) Conservatism of prior decades - meaning early '60s or before - was something that Ronald Reagan's personality and speech exuded. The ctrl-left HATED the very idea. Strong religious beliefs are, and have always been, anathema to Communists around the world. They have Communism to believe in - there is no god but Marx, and Lenin Øb☭ma is (now) his Prophet. (George Floyd is Martyr-in-Chief.)

Though Feminism had been around in a serious iteration for nearly 2 decades, and it'd been about the same time since the immigration flood started, America was still a White-man-run Christian country 42 years ago. One could find plenty of small failings of this majority - it was not Heaven on Earth, and not everyone in this majority was so moral.

TV Evangelists Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker, in their better days:



Remember that pair? They were real pieces of work, one might say. Widespread viewing of TV was only 2, and, as a stretch, 3 decades old when the power of TV to evangelize on Sunday mornings to millions had gotten that big. Big money corrupts, and these 2 (allegedly) had let it corrupt them greatly. People who I'd have to call suckers sent in money to these and other corrupt Christian(?) "leaders". I will make the important note here that this was these suckers' OWN MONEY. Too bad, so sad, but not my problem as a taxpayer.

That gets us toward the point of this post. That is, for some years, maybe starting before the Reagan years, but definitely during and then well into the '90s, the ctrl-left pushed a brand of fear-mongering about the right wanting to implement an American Christian Theocracy. Now, it IS possible these people were THAT stupid, but otherwise they were lying sacks of shit when it came to that charge. Not all American Christians at the time were Libertarians (I WISHED!), but these were patriots - for ill or good - who did believe in the founding principles of the country. The left didn't, BTW.* There was absolutely NOBODY on the right, at any kind of political political level I ever heard from, who pushed for US Gov't control of religion.

The ctrl-left had been anti-Christian for a long time already, having started with the school prayer and Christmas pageants. I suppose the Moral Majority idea scared them, in that their continual struggle to push Christianity out of America might be headed off at the pass by Reagan and cohorts. So they came up with this idea that the Moral Majority was planning on implementing The Handmaid's Tale** in America. (I assume the handmaids would be the Brooke Shields, Cheryl Tiegs, Phoebe Cates, and Christy Brinklies, so it honestly didn't sound so awfully bad to me ...)

I have nothing against Punk Rock. However, at that time in American music, there was so much other great stuff that Punk Rock was not an interest. I did go see The Clash though - good show. I only know The Dead Kennedys from decades later, but what I gather is that they were suckers for the ctrl-left bullshit story on the attempt at an American Christian Theocracy.

The 5th verse of Moral Majority per Dieter Kief***:
Blow it out your ass, Jerry Falwell!
Blow it out your ass, Jesse Helms!
Blow it out your ass, Ronald Reagan!
What's wrong with a mind of my own?
You don't want abortions, you want battered children.
You want to ban the pill as if that solves the problem.
Now you wanna force us to pray in school.
God must be dead if you're such a fool.
Jerry Falwell was not one of those involved in the monetary corruption scandals of the early 1980s. If you didn't like him, he could be turned off. We could use 100 Jesse Helm's in the Senate. I really miss guys like that. (The closest in spirit we've got now, IMO, are the Matt Gaetzs and MTGs.) Ronnie (with lots of help) won the Cold War, keeping The Dead Kennedys safer from nuclear Armageddon, so ...

The rest of the verse is also falsehoods. Nobody wanted to FORCE anyone into any religious practice. Abortion is another story.

Verse 4:
Stodgy ayatollahs in their dobble-knit ties
burn lots of books so they can feed you their lies,
masturbating with a flag and a Bible.
God must be dead if you're alive.
They understood who would create an ACTUAL theorcracy:

Dearborn, Michigan, USA(?):



DuckDuckGo "dead kennedys anti muslim songs":

Search results:
Not many results contain muslim
Search only for death kennedys anti "muslim" songs?
Wherever the Moslem Theocracy may reign, I don't think The Dead Kennedys will be able to book a venue. Just keeping their heads would be a good day!


* They cared greatly about specific Constitutional principles back in the '60s... because those principles kept them from serious jail time.

** There's more to that story though. Pollution had made most women infertile, I just read on the IMDB page. That was 1990 though - now it'd be the Climate Calamity™ that had made them infertile. I would choose Greta Thunburg as my handmaid, with a happy happy ending. "Oh, Greta, how dare you?!"

*** Any typos are due to 1) Dieter Kief, 2) the internet, and 3) The Dead Kennedys themselves, in reverse order of likeliness. (I always put in punctuation though.)

Comments:
Moderator
Monday - January 22nd 2024 8:29AM MST
PS: I didn't catch your comment until just now, J1234. Thanks. You have a good feel for the times and how things have changed. Yes, that Tipper Gore campaign against the dirty lyrics would be something anyone of the D-squad today would be extremely embarrassed to have even brought up from his/her past.

Thanks for that info on the CPUSA too. I didn't even know there had been and was such a thing until the '00s or so.
Moderator
Friday - January 19th 2024 10:47AM MST
PS: I pretty much agree, Alarmist, but I'll stay off that issue. This led to Mr. Hail's comment - Mr. Sailer sometimes puts a lot of thought into the stats and reasons for things that those on certain bandwagons (legal abortion saved us from more grief) may not want to hear. I don't know about that issue, but I do remember that he looked into crime in Miami and that crack "epidemic" and violence being purely a result of that Carter boner called the Mariel Boat Lift (125,000? Cuban criminals released to S. Florida), and I though that was very good thinking.

I read C.J. Hopkin's article, Dieter. Thanks for that! I've got more to say about that, but it'll have to be later ...
J1234
Friday - January 19th 2024 10:46AM MST
PS-
"I don't know how religious President Ronald Reagan really was, but he was less overtly Christian than his predecessor Jimmy Carter. However, as Conservative as he may seem now, Jimmy was politically with the ctrl-left of the time..."

True about Carter. It's possible his religiosity was played up a bit to appeal to black church lady voters back then, but he was probably sincere about his faith, such as it was. He fit the profile of Christians of the Democratic party in the '70's and '80's - they had a very strong streak of "social gospel" running through them. Some - like Al Gore's wife - were even willing to take a stand on Christian principles that were unpopular with significant segments of the left. I wasn't particularly a fan of Tipper, but she was a symbol of how (relatively) little Us vs. Them (i.e., Dem vs. Rep) thinking there was among the Democrats of her day. To her, the "Us vs. Them" meant those who were civilized vs. those who weren't. I can go along with that.

"Strong religious beliefs are, and have always been, anathema to Communists...."

It was in the late '80's that the Communist Party USA stopped running their own presidential candidates and instead started endorsing Democratic party candidates. No Democratic presidential candidate since/including Michael Dukakis has ever disavowed or renounced endorsement by the CPUSA (the only political organization in the history of the US to be outlawed by an act of congress.) So, was there a new unholy alliance being forged at that time between between the naive but basically benign progressives of the Democratic party and the virulent atheistic radicals of far left America? I can't say...maybe it took place before that, maybe after that. I know there was something of an alliance that existed back in FDR's New Deal and later during the HUAC McCarthy days, but Dems like Truman, JFK and even LBJ - as great as their faults could be - were willing to acknowledge the threat of Communism, each in their own way.
Moderator
Friday - January 19th 2024 10:42AM MST
PS: Mr.Blanc, perhaps the Founders just looked at some of the colonies that were expectedly religious in their founding and governments, and just didn't want the Federal Gov. being formed to go in that direction. However, the differences, as you wrote, were not large - different denominations of Protestantism and some offbeat few - Quakers, Shakers, what have you, and then the Catholics. All were Christian - even those Unitarians who are now pretty much "we believe there is up to one god, no more than that." (I'm butchering that joke cause I can't find it!) were straight-laced Christians out of Boston back then.

Would they have been fine with large masses of Moslems moving here? I think not, and I think they might have hesitated on that portion of Amendment I were it the case.

We have all kinds now, and, as you wrote, even homegrown new-agers are just one more diverse part of the array of religions. It worked for a while... but after 60 years of large-scale immigration ...?
Adam Smith
Friday - January 19th 2024 8:29AM MST
PS: Good morning, Mr. Hail!

Better Angels of Our Nature by Steven Pinker
http://tinyurl.com/jsjwpa22

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1238971734063226881.html

Thanks for the update on C.J. Hopkins. A little hard to believe the criminals masquerading as "the government of Germany" are still persecuting Mr. Hopkins for heresy. Did they not get the memo that PanicFest is over?

I too hope Dieter can pull some strings and get Mr. Hopkins' case dismissed with prejudice.

☮️
Hail
Friday - January 19th 2024 6:27AM MST
PS

correction -- "IF he is found innocent," Hopkins suggests he'll buy coffees for diehard supporters, after walking free from the court.

Will C. J. Hopkins be found innocent or guilty? Will Dieter Kief pull strings high-up in the government to get C. J.Hopkins a kinder judge and, if necessary, a more-spacious jail-cell and speedy release?

See--

https://consentfactory.org/2024/01/16/meet-the-thought-police/
Hail
Friday - January 19th 2024 6:21AM MST
PS

-- C. J. Hopkins on trial --

It seems that C. J. Hopkins is finally being put on trial in Berlin, Germany, this coming week, with a court-date of Jan 23, 2024.

He has stood accused, for almost two years now, of:

-- Corona-Denialism,

-- Offenses against public-health (urging people to NOT wear masks);

and, possibly:

-- Defamation against government authorities for alleging malicious conspiracies by the German government to take away people's rights,

-- and personal-attacks against German Minister of Health Lauterbach (whom I once called "Germany's Wrongest Man").

Hopkins invites his fans to come to the courtroom, as guests are allowed. He suggests that he is found innocent he will pay for coffees for all his fans. If he is dragged away, he'll at least have witnesses.
Hail
Friday - January 19th 2024 1:30AM MST
PS

RE: The Alarmist,

-- On the death penalty (and abortion)'s possible eugenic effect --

Dr Peter Frost, in the 2010s in direct response to the Steven Pinker book "Better Angels of Our Nature," showed that there is reason to believe violence declined in the West in great part due to heavy use of the death-penalty. Over a period of centuries, the death-penalty liberally applied took out the antisocial violent elements from the gene-pool.

Steven Pinker's argument in "Better Angels of Our Nature" had deemphasized a "gene-pool" component and had much happy-talk about democracy and such, Enlightenment Values leading to a reduction in violence. I think Steve Sailer had much to say about the Pinker book back then (early 2010s):

https://www.theamericanconservative.com/steven-pinkers-peace-studies/

Steve Sailer back in 2011 was still willing to make forays into open criticism of our Hebrew friends, and he made some carefully worded attacks on Pinker as a member of that religio-ethnic group with biases typical of that group, which influenced his thinking on the supposed savage state of medieval Europe and the supposed placid nonviolence after the Emancipation of that religious group and dismantling of traditional hostile and restrictive policies against that group.

As for abortion, Steve Sailer was for years in back-and-forth argument about whether legalized abortion caused the decline in crime or not. Maybe surprisingly, Sailer opposed the idea. The Sailer critics of the ca. 2020 period, of which there are many regulars in his own comment-section, might say this is his fuddy-duddy-conservative instincts at work. Cf also his recent high interest in Black Traffic-Accident Statistics (as Je Suis Omar Mateen puts it).

"You keep hearing this abortion cuts crime theory because it sounds so politically incorrect that it has to be true, but, judging from the historical record, it’s at least as likely that legalizing abortion contributed to this vast murder spree." -- Steve Sailer, May 2003
The Alarmist
Thursday - January 18th 2024 1:19PM MST
PS

The video I linked to scrolled the lyrics so you could follow along: It is truly amazing how Jello Biafra could deliver all that verbosity at such a pace.

A Christian Theocracy isn’t looking so bad now that we’re experiencing the left’s brave new DIE world.

I think abortion is an abomination, but I’m cool with it since majority of people seeking abortions are precisely the ones we don’t want reproducing. In return, they should make up their minds by the 15th week, so that their evil handlers cannot profit off the sale of fetal body parts, which is what they are doing with late-term abortions.

All I ask for being cool with abortion is a reiprocal cool with “liberal” use of the death penalty for serious crimes rather than letting perps rot in prison for decades or, even worse, setting the scum free. Then again, think of all the murderers and rapists who would never have walked the streets if they had been aborted in the first place.

To paraphrase Biafra, every time I hear Buck Sexton read the ad copy from some anti-abortion group talking about saving unborn babies, I can only think...

Blow it out your ass, Buck Sexton!
Dieter Kief
Thursday - January 18th 2024 12:58PM MST
PS

From the outside - - -amen, MBlanc46.
MBlanc46
Thursday - January 18th 2024 12:33PM MST
PS The founders of this republic were diverse enough regarding religion that they built freedom of religion into their fundamental law. The founders were all Christian or Christian-adjacent, so, at least looking from the outside, they weren’t all that diverse. At the beginning of the 20th century, a small but significant number of members of the Tribe began to enter the country. At that point, religious controversy began to increase. Now we’ve got Muslims and Hindus and Sikhs and wacky white people with their New Agey wackazaniness and atheists and God knows what else. And of course, the anti-religious Left, which is something of a religion itself. Each of these groups wants to carve out its own little theocracy. (Except the Left, who want to impose their religion on everyone else with the help of state power.) The Christians are no different, and they have as much right to their piece of the former USA as any of the other groups, if they can take it and hold it.
WHAT SAY YOU? : (PLEASE NOTE: You must type capital PS as the 1st TWO characters in your comment body - for spam avoidance - or the comment will be lost!)
YOUR NAME
Comments